Konjit, esteemed members of this e-forum and facilitators,
I would like to use this as a teaching session since there is so much on my mind . It will be a great disservice if I dont share this with you.
From your submission Konjit, I deduct that a participatory/empowerment model was successfully used that gave people programme ownership from the start. Please accept my compliments for the great work you and Maria Sururu are doing. From reading I am so impressed and want to encourage you even though I have not read the actual published reports on this but I take your word for it
This appears to be a poverty reduction programme/HIV/AIDS/empowerment programme
Initiative: A
Innovation: A
Empowerment: A
Creativity: A
Program Eval: Well you have to post that the forum...I m curious about wider programme impact
Curiously, correct me if I am in error, in Asia and Africa CCMs havnt received favorable reviews during my time with the e-forum since April '08. Interestingly, what has become clear is that the messages came from the grassroots from those that were able to access email. Our collegues on this e-forum will not compromise their character to get our attention by misrepresenting themselves. This again is strikingly clear and an example..the disconnect between the CCM, civil society and the grassroots organizations. For this reason, I am calling for a serious shift in paradigm. This information came very timely as I am writing a major research paper on the MDGs which will be published.
Did any of you with regards to our discussion of the month on: "Program oversight and coordination, read "Achieving the MDGs in Africa: Recommendations of the MDG Africa Steering Group June 2008", which was issued July 2, 2008?
If you didn't, I would like to impress upon you that this e-forum is a matter of life and death for millions of Africans .....and also our people in some parts of SE Asia and the Caribbean. I'm keeping tabs on HIV/AIDS/TB/Malaria and the MDGs around the world.
This I think may be of interest to this e-forum:
|
NEWS
|
|
Kenya’s life expectancy rate rises
Story by PAUL REDFERN, Nation correspondent
Publication Date: 7/7/2008
|
|
Kenya and Uganda are among the top five countries with an improving life expectancy rate in Africa, according to latest statistics released by the United Nations and Britain’s Department for International Development.
The life expectancy rate in Kenya is up by more than three per cent to 54 years while in Uganda it is up by nearly four per cent to 51.5 years.
Uganda’s life expectancy percentage increase is the highest in Africa after Botswana with a life expectancy rate of 50 while Malawi and Zambia make up the other two countries, although in both countries life expectancy rates are low at 43 and 42 years respectively.
Deterioration
Countries showing the worst deterioration in terms of life expectancy – mainly because of the growing number of people with HIV and Aids – are Swaziland, South Africa, Mozambique and Lesotho. All of them have seen rates fall by between two and four per cent.
An estimated 22.5 million people in Africa are now believed to be infected with HIV, with 1.7 million new infections in 2007.Currently, only 2.12 million people are receiving anti-retroviral treatment in Africa. It was hoped that this number would be increased substantially, thanks to Western donor support over the coming decade.
However, those hopes appear to have been dashed with reports that G8 countries are this week preparing to backtrack on key aid pledges, including a promise to provide universal access to Aids treatment.
The pledge “has been a benchmark around which health campaigners and others have been organising their work, especially in Africa,” the Financial Times said.
|
|
|
Then read this one: If I am to go by this latest report in Nigeria...this is not a laughing matter. (Note: Nigeria's population is 140 million)
NEWS
4 July 2008
Posted to the web 4 July 2008
Lagos
Dr Babatunde Osotimehin, Director General, National Agency for the Control of AIDS (NACA), yesterday in Abuja, said Benue still ranked highest in HIV prevalence in Nigeria.
According to him, Benue, in the North-Central region, has 10 per cent prevalence rate, followed by Akwa-Ibom in the South-south zone with eight per cent. Enugu in the South-east has 6.5 per cent, Kaduna in the North-west, 5.6 per cent, Taraba in the North-east, 6.1 per cent, while Ogun in the South-west has 3.6 prevalence rate.
He spoke at a workshop on the creation of budget lines on
HIV and AIDS in federal ministries, departments and agencies.
Osotimehin said a multi-sectoral approach would be needed to curb the epidemic, as the prevalence rate in some states was unacceptable.
The approach is to include ministries, departments, agencies, public, private, civil society, faith-based organisations and the three-tiers of government to fight the scourge," he said.
Osotimehin said the sectoral response would cover key areas such as prevention, treatment, care and support.
Minister of Finance, Dr Shamsudeen Usman, also implored ministries, departments and agencies to support NACA financially.
Represented by Acting Permanent Secretary in the Ministry, Alhaji Jibrin Zarewa, Shamsudeen said the fight against HIV and AIDS should be given priority attention.
He alluded to a report by UNAIDS, indicating that 50 million people had been infected with the virus in the last two years. (Is this really true???)
Back to my comments on the participatory/empowerment model. Were the people in a conflict zone?Was there any hunger or food crisis present during this initiative? If Illiterate or lacking functional literacy skills the people appeared to have been mentored all along. Then if we want to transplant this program in another country or regions we need to look at the culture in general and the leadership provided, their attitude and worldview and other socio-cultural factors that favored such an initiative to be successfull.
An example of outrageously bad governance and PUBLIC INFORMATION: This is what is happening in a neighbouring country with funds....this is the second example in 1 year. The Global Fund had the same experience and now its the WorldBank's turn...my question is when will you people learn? Let us call a spade a spade. On one hand we can't blame this on illiteracy ...this appears to be more of a case of pre-meditated kleptomania. On the other hand, I have never heard of such ...however, I don't rule it out, but it is such an extreme case and I question this entire account. I can understand the story about the receipts nini, but It just doesn't add up and I am suspicious, because this happened in different layers, well planned, perfectly well orchestrated and this is squarely blamed on innocent people under the pretense of illiteracy. This is a big sham and a lesson for the GFnot to make the same mistake. I am posting this for the world to see so that everyone knows what is happening. What lessons are to be learned from this??? They blame this squarely on illiteracy while this is actually a case of ....
Sh2.5 Billion NUSAF Funds Missing
New Vision (Kampala)
NEWS
10 July 2008
Posted to the web 11 July 2008
By Madinah Tebajjukira
Kampala
A TOTAL of sh2.5b of the Northern Uganda Social Action Fund (NUSAF) is unaccounted for, according to the Government.
"An estimated sh2.5b was unaccounted for, out of which sh1.9b was in Kitgum alone," David Wakikona, the state minister for northern Uganda, told Parliament yesterday.
Of the money unaccounted for, at least half was embezzled, according to a report submitted to the House by Prime Minister Prof. Apolo Nsibambi.
The report lists all the organisations and individuals in northern and eastern Uganda who diverted funds.
NUSAF is a government programme, funded by the World Bank to the tune of $113m, meant to eradicate poverty in northern Uganda.
"I take this opportunity to hand over to you the list of people and organisations involved in the NUSAF scandal," Nsibambi said while submitting the list to the presidential affairs committee chairman, Gerald Menhya.
"Some cases are in courts of law while others are being handled by the police. But it is of great importance for the members of parliament to get copies of the alleged corruption."
According to the list, 92 organisations and 28 individuals diverted often huge sums of money.
Embezzlement took all kind of forms. In some cases, members of the Community Project Management Committee (CPMC) connived with contractors to produce shoddy or incomplete work.
In other cases, the supplier never delivered the goods he was paid for. But mostly, money was withdrawn by CPMC executives and diverted for personal use.
Gulu registered the highest number of cases where CPMC executive members took money and disappeared with it.
For example, executive members of the Tempwoyo Youth Community Carpentry and Joinery Project in Paicho sub-county disappeared with sh10m, according to the list.
A total of 92 cases of suspected corruption by organisations are being investigated by the police, the MPs heard.
Fifteen other cases involving conspiracy to commit a felony, theft, embezzlement, causing financial loss and uttering false documents are being prosecuted in the courts.
The biggest case is the theft of sh461,844,000 involving three NUSAF officers in Kitgum. The case is in court.
Minister Wakikona pointed out that high illiteracy levels among the beneficiaries contributed to the mismanagement and embezzlement of funds.
"Most people who got NUSAF funds were illiterate and could not even think of asking for receipts for anything bought. We visited Karamoja and found a woman who had lost sh2m to a group of people who disguised that they were helping her," Wakikona noted.
For the second phase of the programme, he said, district officials will identify groups of 'middle class' educated people to access the funds, who in turn will teach the illiterate people how to account for the money.
"We have identified a solution for NUSAF II. Illiterate people will not receive funds until they have learnt the skills of managing funds."
Livingstone Okello Okello (UPC) noted that some suspects accused of embezzling funds had been released and that this could jeopardize the investigations.
But Nsibambi said that the courts of law are independent institutions. "If the courts of law release them, what can I do? The judiciary is an independent body and we don't interfere in its work."
According to the list, 92 organisations and 28 individuals diverted often huge sums of money.
Embezzlement took all kind of forms.
In some cases, members of the Community Project Management Committee (CPMC) connived with contractors to produce shoddy or incomplete work.
In other cases, the supplier never delivered the goods he was paid for.
But mostly, money was withdrawn by CPMC executives and diverted for personal use.
Gulu registered the highest number of cases where CPMC executive members took money and disappeared with it.
For example, executive members of the Tempwoyo Youth Community Carpentry and Joinery Project in Paicho sub-county disappeared with sh10m, according to the list.
A total of 92 cases of suspected corruption by organisations are being investigated by the police, the MPs heard.
Fifteen other cases involving conspiracy to commit a felony, theft, embezzlement, causing financial loss and uttering false documents are being prosecuted in the courts.
The biggest case is the theft of sh461,844,000 involving three NUSAF officers in Kitgum. The case is in court.
Minister Wakikona pointed out that high illiteracy levels among the beneficiaries contributed to the mismanagement and embezzlement of funds.
"Most people who got NUSAF funds were illiterate and could not even think of asking for receipts for anything bought. We visited Karamoja and found a woman who had lost sh2m to a group of people who disguised that they were helping her," Wakikona noted.
For the second phase of the programme, he said, district officials will identify groups of 'middle class' educated people to access the funds, who in turn will teach the illiterate people how to account for the money.
"We have identified a solution for NUSAF II. Illiterate people will not receive funds until they have learnt the skills of managing funds."
Livingstone Okello Okello (UPC) said some suspects accused of embezzling funds had been released and that this could jeopardise the investigations.
But Nsibambi said the courts of law are independent institutions.
"If the courts of law release them, what can I do? The Judiciary is an independent body and we don't interfere in its work," the premier said.